Does a dog collar help or hinder mission?

Rev Andy Mason is a pioneer minister currently based in Poole who worked until recently in Kingswood, Bristol. He is also currently doing an MA at CMS. Here Andy reflects on an issue facing many people ordained and invited (or required) to wear a clerical collar. In our post-Christian/post-Christendom/post-modern culture does the collar enable mission or get in the way?

“Are you a stripper?”

I stuttered and spluttered as I tried to explain I wasn’t about to get my kit off (I think I’d be the only stripper where people would shout “Put them on!”)

I had just taken up a post as a pioneer minister in Kingswood, Bristol, and was praying around the parish, especially around the reasonably vibrant night-time economy. I had decided that as I was out and about amongst the people I would wear my clerical ‘dog’ collar.

I had recently heard Bishop Lee from Swindon say: “You probably have already decided when you will or won’t wear your collar. I would suggest that some of you should wear it a little less than you think you should, some of you should wear it a little more.” In other words, the collar is a tool, and we need to be wise and prayerful about wearing or not wearing it.

Some people say: “the collar puts people off” and that “it is a barrier for evangelism”, citing that on occasions people will behave differently around you in the collar, and that wearing a collar changes the dynamic to one of ‘provider/client’. Yet this has not been my experience. I have discovered wearing a collar out and about, in pubs, coffee shops and places where people hang out, that the collar has opened conversations and given me opportunities I would not have had if I was just another scruffy bloke. Yet, if I had been doing more mission just as ‘a random scruffy bloke’ (rather than collared up) would that have modelled something to my congregation who don’t wear dog collars when they go to work or football training (or wherever) about sharing my faith?

That said, sitting in a coffee shop (or wherever) in your collar praying for opportunity to engage with local people was/is difficult. It takes time for people to feel comfortable to be able to talk to you.

I remember hearing someone say of clergy that the two key qualities were ‘integrity and approachability’ – yet how can we be approachable when we are on mission under-cover?

The question I asked myself was: “How can I make it as easy as possible for people to talk to me about God/life/faith/Jesus/pain/anything in The King’s Arms” (where we eventually planted a congregation)? Often a pint would appear in front of me, followed by a person asking a big question about life. They did this because I was visible and making myself available.

I believe that, on occasions, the collar has been a catalyst for Kingdom opportunities where I have been able to talk to people who might never have walked into a Church building, putting a human (and smiling) face on the faceless institution of the (often invisible) Church.

I have found that wearing the collar has made it easier for me to offer to pray, to meet up again, or to talk about Jesus. People aren’t surprised when a vicar talks about spiritual things. I feel I am being up front with people about who I am and why I am there. Indeed, it felt like a prophetic statement about my desire to build Church amongst the people I was meeting.

However, within the context of the church community I rarely wore the collar. They knew who I was, and wearing the collar when chairing a PCC or leading a house-group felt like it spoke of hierarchy and power, where I wanted to emphasise team, collaboration and family.

My thinking around clerical collars led me into an interesting wider discussion with Street Pastors, the Salvation Army, and projects like ‘The Noise’ – all of which wear distinctive clothes to be a visible presence in the community. My Street Pastors would say wearing their uniform helped them remember who they were and why they were there – and for the more introverted of us gave us extra confidence! Yet with these groups everyone, the whole team, wears the uniform (not just the vicar in the collar) – which feels like a better message, that we are all in this together.

More recently, after 10 years in ordained ministry, I am taking a break to think and explore where God is calling me, embracing the new challenge of discovering the disciple again from behind the dog collar, who I am, and who God has called me to be.

Does this future involve wearing a dog collar?

I don’t know, but hopefully people won’t think I’m a stripper!

3 thoughts on “Does a dog collar help or hinder mission?”

  1. Thanks for this Andy, really helpful. As a curate still in that ‘will I be a with or without dog collar vicar’ it’s really helpful seeing someone else’s thoughts to add to my own – and to see the similar experience of not having felt it putting people off in the way i’d Imagined it might do – i’m In a majority Muslim parish where i’m Actually finding the public presence opens up doors I wasn’t expecting it to!

  2. Thank you Andy for your perspective.
    I have been ordained now for four years. I also have a job in a school, where a significant proportion of the staff and pupils are Muslim.
    I have found that the Muslim women particularly feel able to talk to me as I wear a collar. I have also found that as I walk around my Parish people expect to say hello,and stop for a chat when I wear my collar, but they just scowl at me if I try the same thing without a collar. I have also had people come into a coffee shop to talk to me, having seen the collar. I can’t imagine someone who does not know me doing that, if I am not wearing a collar. I am careful in church to distinguish between things where I am acting a Priest, when I wear my collar, and things when I am being a member of the congregation, when I do not.
    For me wearing my collar is a very positive thing.

  3. Such a helpful article – and I speak as a Street Pastor who had just been ordained as a permanent deacon – so the need to be “identifiable” resonates. The ordinal describes my vocation as one of “visible self giving” – which suggests to me that this is rather important!

Comments are closed.

Cookie Configuration

We use cookies on our website to ensure you have the best browsing experience. Read our Privacy Policy for more information.

These cookies are necessary for the function of the website and cannot be disabled. They are used to save your preferences as you interact with our website, such as your cookie settings.

These cookies allow us to measure traffic on our website. They help us to know which pages are popular and see how visitors move around the site. All information these cookies collect is aggregated and therefore anonymous.

These cookies are required for some of the core functionality of the website. They are set by third party content providers, such as video players and maps. If disabled, these content providers will not be loaded.


We use cookies on our website to ensure you have the best browsing experience. Read our Privacy Policy for more information.

Configure Cookies Accept